Political debate topics
410 questions people genuinely argue about, across eight areas of policy. Each one is a live debate on Policon: take a side, get matched with someone on the other one, and make your case.
Economy & Taxation63 questions
- Workers should have representatives on the boards of large companies.
- Governments should guarantee a job to everyone who wants one.
- Capital gains should be taxed at the same rate as wages.
- Essential industries should be protected from foreign ownership.
- Free-trade agreements give corporations too much power over governments.
- Countries should tax imports made under weaker labor standards.
- Society would be fairer if every adult started with the same amount of capital.
- Tariffs are worth higher prices if they bring manufacturing home.
- Government should cap the price of rent and essentials when the cost of living spikes.
- Tariff revenue should be handed back to households as cash rather than spent by government.
- Cryptocurrency should be taxed and regulated exactly like any other financial asset.
- A company that replaces workers with AI should pay for the ones it displaced.
- The rich should pay a wealth tax of 2% a year on wealth above $50M.
- The minimum wage should be a living wage, even if some jobs disappear.
- Billionaires are a policy failure.
- Globalization has done more harm than good for ordinary workers.
- Governments should break up companies simply for being too big.
- Degrowth is a serious economic strategy rather than a luxury belief.
- If a machine can do your job more cheaply, society should still pay you to do it.
- Inheritance beyond a modest sum should be abolished.
- Small farmers should be kept in business with public money, even if food gets more expensive.
- Basic utilities like electricity and water should be publicly owned.
- The standard workweek should be cut to four days without cutting pay.
- Company boards should be required by law to include a minimum share of women.
- The constitutional debt brake should be loosened so the state can borrow to invest.
- Cash must remain a means of payment that every shop is required to accept.
- Cities with severe housing shortages should be allowed to cap rents by law.
- Your country gets more out of EU membership than it puts in.
- Cities should sharply limit tourist rentals even at the cost of tourism income.
- A country with runaway inflation should abandon its own currency for the dollar.
- Strategic minerals like lithium should be extracted only by state-owned companies.
- Protecting lifetime employment matters more than making it easier to hire and fire.
- The consumption tax should be cut even at the cost of the public debt.
- Tax and benefit rules that discourage second earners from working full-time should be scrapped.
- The country should adopt the euro.
- Market rents should replace the negotiated rent-setting system.
- The tax deduction for mortgage interest should be abolished.
- An extra tax on the highest incomes should be reintroduced.
- Payroll taxes on employers should be replaced by a tax on company revenue.
- Young workers should pay reduced income tax for their first years in work.
- Fuel and bread subsidies should be replaced with cash payments to poor households.
- Sovereign wealth funds should invest at home rather than abroad.
- A country should accept currency devaluation as a condition of an international loan.
- Employers should be required to fill a fixed share of their jobs with citizens.
- Workers in essential services should keep the right to strike.
- Gig-economy workers should be legally treated as employees.
- Tipping should be replaced by higher wages.
- Companies should be banned from buying back their own shares.
- Working from home should be a legal right wherever the job allows it.
- Unpaid internships should be illegal.
- Every country should apply one high global minimum rate of corporate tax.
- Failing banks should be allowed to collapse, never bailed out.
- Everyone's tax return should be public, as it is in Norway.
- Advertising aimed at children should be banned.
- Central banks should be put under direct democratic control.
- Zoning that allows only single-family houses should be abolished.
- Foreign buyers should be banned from buying homes.
- Second homes should be taxed heavily.
- Landlords who own more than a handful of homes should pay much higher taxes.
- Meritocracy is a myth.
- The rich have a moral duty to give away most of their wealth.
- Executives should be personally criminally liable when their company breaks the law.
- Central banks should issue digital currencies.
Immigration & Borders33 questions
- Children born in a country should automatically receive citizenship.
- Employers should face much harsher penalties for hiring unauthorized workers.
- Local police should help enforce national immigration law.
- Refugees should be distributed among wealthy countries by a binding quota.
- Climate displacement should qualify someone for refugee protection.
- Countries should favor immigrants from culturally similar societies.
- If borders disappeared tomorrow, global inequality would shrink rather than deepen.
- Immigration officers should be required to show their faces and identify themselves during arrests.
- Someone who entered illegally should remain deportable no matter how long they have lived there.
- Deportation numbers are the right measure of whether immigration policy is working.
- People who arrived illegally but built a life should be able to get citizenship.
- Border enforcement should come before any expansion of legal immigration.
- Skilled immigrants should be prioritized over family reunification.
- Rich countries have a duty to take in refugees.
- Multiculturalism strengthens a nation more than it divides it.
- There should be an upper limit on asylum numbers.
- A world with open borders would be a utopia rather than a catastrophe.
- It is unfair that where you are born decides most of your life chances.
- All undocumented immigrants should be deported, including those who have lived peacefully in the country for many years.
- European countries should accept substantially more refugees even if a majority of their citizens oppose doing so.
- Asylum seekers who enter Europe illegally should be automatically returned to a safe country outside the EU while their claims are processed.
- Citizenship should depend primarily on cultural assimilation, not merely legal residence or place of birth.
- Naturalized citizens should be allowed to keep their original citizenship.
- Large-scale immigration is the right answer to a shrinking population.
- Public employees should be required to report undocumented migrants they encounter in their work.
- The state should pay a large grant to migrants who choose to leave the country for good.
- Citizenship should require passing a language test.
- Migrants arriving in large numbers at one border should be moved to other regions by the national government.
- Immigrants should hold a work contract before they may apply to regularise their status.
- A migrant worker should be free to change employer without their current employer's permission.
- Long-term foreign residents should be able to obtain citizenship.
- A transit country should stop migrant boats leaving for Europe in exchange for European funding.
- Foreign residents should be able to vote in local elections.
Climate & Energy44 questions
- Electricity consumers should pay more now to build a zero-carbon grid faster.
- New oil and gas drilling on public land should be prohibited.
- Homeowners should be required to replace fossil-fuel heating when it wears out.
- Countries should impose carbon tariffs on high-emission imports.
- Protecting biodiversity should take priority over building renewable-energy infrastructure.
- Governments should ration high-carbon activities such as frequent flying.
- Deliberately reviving extinct species counts as environmental restoration.
- Keeping electricity bills down matters more right now than cutting emissions faster.
- The government should ban new gas-powered cars by 2035.
- Nuclear power should be the backbone of a clean grid.
- Fossil fuel companies should pay for climate damages the way tobacco companies did.
- Rich nations owe climate reparations to poor ones.
- Economic growth is compatible with saving the climate.
- Developing countries should get to burn coal like the West once did.
- Geoengineering the atmosphere would be justified if warming passes 2°C.
- Having fewer children is a legitimate climate policy.
- Europe should abandon deadlines for banning new petrol and diesel cars if those deadlines harm industrial competitiveness or working-class consumers.
- Governments should impose aggressive carbon taxes and restrictions on flying, driving, and meat consumption even if they substantially raise the cost of living.
- There should be a general speed limit on the motorway.
- Phasing out nuclear power is a mistake.
- Local communities should be able to veto wind farms in their area.
- Traditional hunting should be protected even when animal-welfare campaigners object.
- Nuclear reactors idled after a disaster should be restarted once regulators approve.
- Commercial whaling is a legitimate cultural tradition.
- The state should finance new nuclear reactors with public money.
- The biofuel blending requirement for petrol and diesel should be raised again even if fuel gets more expensive.
- Large infrastructure projects should be exempt from full environmental licensing.
- Lithium mining should go ahead in protected rural areas to supply the energy transition.
- A country should be able to dam a shared river without the agreement of the countries downstream.
- Farming should be restricted where it draws groundwater faster than it refills.
- Private cars should be banned from city centres.
- Public transport should be free at the point of use.
- Congestion charges are a fair way for cities to raise money.
- Flights should be banned on routes where a train takes less than four hours.
- Factory farming should be phased out.
- School and hospital canteens should serve mainly plant-based food.
- Lab-grown meat should be allowed to be sold as meat.
- Future generations will judge eating meat the way we now judge slavery.
- Private jets should be banned.
- Climate activists who block roads or damage artworks should go to prison.
- Individual lifestyle changes matter little for the environment compared with system-wide policy.
- Single-use plastic packaging should be banned for most consumer goods.
- Rich countries should be banned from exporting their waste.
- Countries that miss their climate targets should face international sanctions.
Healthcare & Welfare50 questions
- Medical debt should be legally erased after a short period.
- Public universities should charge no tuition.
- Paid parental leave should be mandatory for every employer.
- Wealthy retirees should receive the same public benefits as poor retirees.
- Governments should fund childcare as a universal public service.
- Private health insurance should be allowed to buy faster access to essential care.
- If longevity treatments remain scarce, younger people should get priority.
- Health-insurance subsidies should be restored even if it means a bigger deficit.
- A pension shortfall should be closed by raising taxes rather than by trimming benefits.
- Everyone in a country should get medical care, including people living there illegally.
- Healthcare should be free at the point of use, funded by taxes.
- Welfare benefits should come with work requirements.
- The state should guarantee housing as a right.
- A universal basic income is the future of the welfare state.
- Generous benefits make people less willing to work.
- Private schools should be abolished to level the playing field.
- If poverty is solvable, tolerating it is a moral crime.
- Parenting licenses should exist the way driving licenses do.
- Abortion should be legal on request throughout pregnancy.
- Abortion should be illegal from conception except when necessary to save the mother’s life.
- Minors should not be permitted to receive puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, or gender-transition surgery.
- The retirement age should rise as people live longer.
- Declining rural regions should be kept alive with public money rather than left to empty out.
- Smartphones should be banned from schools entirely.
- Private full-coverage health insurance should be folded into one public system for everyone.
- Pensions should keep rising even as a shrinking workforce pays an ever larger share.
- A fixed share of parental leave should be reserved for fathers.
- Paid menstrual leave should be a legal right.
- Regions with their own language should be allowed to run schools mainly in that language.
- University admission should be decided by exam results alone.
- Companies should be banned from making a profit on publicly funded schools.
- The state should take over responsibility for healthcare from the regions.
- The unpaid first day of sick leave should be abolished.
- Cash transfers to poor families should be paid only while their children stay in school.
- The public health service should buy capacity from private hospitals to cut waiting lists.
- Citizens should receive a share of oil revenue as a direct annual payment.
- The public payroll should be cut even if it means large-scale redundancies.
- Standardised testing should be abolished in schools.
- Student debt should be cancelled.
- Schools should teach personal finance in place of advanced mathematics.
- Teachers' pay should depend on their pupils' results.
- Primary schools should not give grades.
- Young people today have it harder than their parents did.
- Assisted dying should be legal for terminally ill adults.
- Assisted dying should be available to people whose suffering is purely psychiatric.
- Organ donation should be opt-out instead of opt-in.
- People should be allowed to sell their own kidneys.
- Sugary food should be taxed like tobacco.
- Tobacco should be phased out by banning its sale to anyone born after a set year.
- Psychedelics should be legal for therapeutic use.
Policing, Guns & Security43 questions
- Police officers should lose qualified immunity from civil lawsuits.
- Firearm owners should be required to carry liability insurance.
- Cash bail should be abolished even if some defendants reoffend before trial.
- Facial-recognition surveillance should be banned in public spaces.
- Prisons should prioritize rehabilitation over punishment in every case.
- Governments should negotiate with terrorist groups to save hostages.
- Perfect prediction of violent crime would justify arrest before an offense occurs.
- Sending soldiers into cities to fight crime is legitimate when local policing has failed.
- Federal forces should never operate in a city over the objection of its elected government.
- Governments should be able to declare emergencies that suspend the normal limits on policing.
- A government that loses the public's trust loses the right to use force.
- Ordinary citizens should be able to own firearms for self-defense.
- Police budgets should be partly redirected into social programs.
- Tougher sentences deter crime.
- Mass surveillance is an acceptable price for preventing terrorism.
- The death penalty should be abolished everywhere.
- Drugs should be decriminalized across the board.
- Trading a little liberty for a guarantee of safety would be worth it.
- Rioting is sometimes a legitimate form of protest.
- European countries should reintroduce compulsory military service for all young adults, including women.
- People convicted of exceptionally serious crimes should be eligible for the death penalty.
- The domestic intelligence service should be allowed to surveil parties it classifies as extremist.
- The age of criminal responsibility should be lowered for serious violent crime.
- Occupying a long-empty home should be tolerated when people have nowhere to live.
- Police should be able to search people in designated zones without concrete suspicion.
- Witnesses should be allowed to testify anonymously in trials against gang criminals.
- Ordinary citizens should be allowed to carry a firearm outside the home.
- Prisoners should keep the right to temporary release on public holidays.
- Military service should be compulsory for women as well as men.
- Civilians should never be tried in a military court.
- A year of civilian or military service should be compulsory for young people.
- Cannabis should be legal and sold the way alcohol is.
- Juries and lay judges should be replaced by professional judges.
- Life sentences without the possibility of parole should be abolished.
- Victims should have a say in the sentences given to their offenders.
- Ordinary police officers should not carry guns.
- Criminal records for non-violent offences should be wiped after a fixed period.
- People should be allowed to use lethal force to defend their property.
- Children should never be tried as adults, whatever the crime.
- Sex-offender registries should be open to the public.
- Repeat sex offenders should be offered chemical castration in exchange for shorter sentences.
- Citizens who join terrorist groups abroad should lose their citizenship.
- Citizens who joined terrorist groups abroad should be brought home to stand trial.
Foreign Policy & Geopolitics51 questions
- Military aid should require recipients to meet strict human-rights conditions.
- A country should defend an ally even when doing so risks a major war.
- Foreign lobbying should face the same restrictions as foreign campaign donations.
- Permanent members should lose their veto on the UN Security Council.
- Economic sanctions are an ethical alternative to war.
- Democratic countries should boycott major events hosted by authoritarian states.
- A single world government would prevent war rather than create an unstoppable tyranny.
- Striking another country's nuclear facilities without declaring war is sometimes justified.
- Countries that keep trading with an adversary should be sanctioned themselves.
- Closing a strategic waterway is an act of war that justifies a military response.
- A ceasefire is worth signing even when the other side has promised nothing binding.
- The world is safer with one dominant superpower than with several rivals.
- Your country should put its own interests first, even when allies object.
- Defense spending should rise even at the cost of social programs.
- Withdrawing from foreign wars was strength rather than abdication.
- International bodies like the UN should be able to override national governments.
- Arming other democracies under attack is a duty rather than a gamble.
- Trade with authoritarian states should be conditional on human rights.
- If your country were invaded, resistance would be a duty for everyone.
- Patriotism is a virtue rather than a bias.
- Ukraine should accept permanent Russian control of some occupied territory if that is necessary to end the war.
- Ukraine should permanently renounce NATO membership in exchange for a peace agreement with Russia.
- The United States should go to war with China if China attempts to conquer Taiwan by force.
- Military strikes on Iran are justified if they are necessary to prevent Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon.
- European NATO members should build the military capacity to defend Europe without relying on the United States.
- Western countries should impose a comprehensive arms embargo on Israel until it accepts the establishment of a Palestinian state.
- Western countries should deliberately reduce their economic dependence on China even if doing so makes ordinary consumers significantly poorer.
- Foreign aid should be defunded such that poor countries learn to support themselves.
- A Palestinian state should be internationally recognized even without an agreement with Israel.
- Iran would be justified in acquiring nuclear weapons if Israel continues to possess them.
- The state of Israel should be sanctioned.
- More European countries should acquire or jointly control nuclear weapons rather than relying primarily on the American nuclear umbrella.
- NATO countries should be willing to send combat troops into Ukraine even if doing so creates a serious risk of direct war with Russia.
- Former colonial powers owe reparations to the countries they colonized.
- The EU should develop into a federal state with its own army.
- Ukraine should be admitted to the EU even if it is costly for current members.
- National vetoes in EU decision-making should be abolished.
- The constitution's renunciation of war should be revised to openly recognize the armed forces.
- Hosting foreign military bases makes the country safer, not less sovereign.
- Defence spending should rise to 3.5 percent of GDP even if it means cuts elsewhere.
- Trade between emerging economies should be settled in their own currencies rather than the dollar.
- Normalising relations with Israel should require a Palestinian state first.
- Borders between neighbouring states should reopen even where a territorial dispute is unresolved.
- Nuclear deterrence has made the world safer.
- Rich countries should cancel the debts of the poorest nations.
- Museums should return colonial-era artefacts to the countries they came from.
- Private military contractors should be banned.
- Military intervention to stop a genocide is justified even without UN approval.
- Weapons should never be sold to countries at war.
- Spying on allies is acceptable.
- Resources in space should belong to all of humanity, not whoever reaches them first.
Technology & Civil Liberties45 questions
- Political campaigns should be forbidden from using deepfakes, even when labeled.
- Dominant technology platforms should be regulated like public utilities.
- Police should need a warrant to buy personal location data from brokers.
- Governments should require licenses to train the most powerful AI systems.
- People should have a legal right to delete their past from search engines.
- Autonomous weapons should be prohibited by international treaty.
- If a digital copy of you were conscious, deleting it would be killing.
- Communities should be able to block data centers even when the country needs the capacity.
- Chatbots should be prohibited from acting as therapists or companions for minors.
- A handful of AI companies now hold more power than a democracy can tolerate.
- AI firms should pay for every copyrighted work their models were trained on.
- If AI eliminated most jobs, that would be liberation rather than catastrophe.
- The government should be able to read encrypted messages with a warrant.
- Social platforms should be liable for what their algorithms promote.
- Foreign-owned apps like TikTok should be banned on security grounds.
- AI development should be slowed by regulation, even at the cost of innovation.
- Online anonymity is a right worth protecting.
- Platforms should remove hateful content even at some cost to free speech.
- If an AI could vote better than the average citizen, it should be allowed to.
- Targeted advertising should be banned entirely.
- Social-media companies should be required to remove demonstrably false political information even when doing so restricts political speech.
- Democratic governments should be allowed to ban political parties that they determine pose a fundamental threat to liberal democracy.
- AI companies should be allowed to train models on publicly accessible copyrighted books, art, journalism, and websites without obtaining individual permission.
- Governments should be allowed to use mass facial recognition and AI surveillance in public places to prevent serious crime and terrorism.
- Public broadcasting should keep its mandatory fees.
- Authorities should be allowed to scan private messages to find child-abuse material.
- Police should be allowed to use facial recognition cameras in public places to fight gang crime.
- Platforms should be liable for a user's post without a court order telling them to remove it.
- Broadcasters and social accounts should need a licence to publish news.
- Online voting should replace paper ballots.
- Loot boxes in video games should be regulated as gambling.
- Self-driving cars should be legal once they kill fewer people than human drivers do.
- Parents should not be allowed to earn money from posting their children online.
- Editing human embryos' genes to prevent disease should be allowed.
- Parents should be allowed to select embryos for intelligence.
- Pornography sites should be required to verify users' age by ID.
- Humanity has a duty to settle other planets.
- Algorithmic social-media feeds should be switched off by default.
- Governments should fund local journalism directly.
- Art generated by AI should not be eligible for copyright.
- Employers should be banned from monitoring employees' screens and keystrokes.
- AI chatbots should be banned from answering questions about elections.
- Every citizen should be required to have a digital ID.
- Companies should have to disclose whenever a customer is talking to an AI.
- If ending all poverty meant giving up all privacy, it would be worth it.
Social & Cultural Issues81 questions