Kialo is one of the best-known debate sites online, and for good reason: its argument trees are a genuinely clear way to see the structure of a disagreement. But people go looking for an alternative for a few recurring reasons, and the right alternative depends on which one is yours.
What Kialo does well
Kialo lays an argument out as a tree. A thesis sits at the top, and every claim beneath it is a pro or a con, which can have pros and cons of its own. It is written, asynchronous and collaborative: many people build one map together, and the result is often the most complete overview of an issue you can find in one place. Its education version is widely used in classrooms.
If what you want is to understand a question thoroughly, it is hard to improve on, and you may not need an alternative at all.
Why people look for something else
"I want an actual opponent"
An argument map has contributors, not an opponent. Nobody answers you in real time, and there is no result. If what you are missing is the experience of making a case to someone who disagrees and is about to reply, you want a head-to-head format: either a written rounds-based debate site, or a live one.
"I want to practise speaking, not writing"
Writing and speaking are different skills. A great written argument can fall apart out loud, when you have ten seconds to answer a point you did not expect. If your goal is to get better in conversations, meetings, interviews or competitive debate, you need practice that happens live.
"I want to know how I did"
Kialo has votes on how impactful a claim is, but no judge and no record of how you, personally, are improving. Some people want feedback and a measure of progress.
The alternatives, by what you are missing
- A written opponent and a result: rounds-based debate sites in the DebateArt mould, where two people post arguments in turn and members vote on the winner.
- Someone to persuade: Reddit's r/changemyview, where a poster awards a delta to whoever changes their mind.
- A live opponent, by voice, with a judge: Policon.
- A model to learn from: Open to Debate (formerly Intelligence Squared U.S.), where experts argue a motion and the audience votes before and after.
We cover each of these in more detail in our guide to the best online debate platforms.
Kialo and Policon, side by side
We make Policon, so read this with that in mind. The two are built for different jobs, and plenty of people would be well served by both.
- Format: Kialo is a written map built by many people over time. Policon is a live, one-on-one (or team) voice debate that lasts five, ten or fifteen minutes.
- Opponent: Kialo has none as such. Policon matches you with a real person whose politics differ from yours, on questions you both choose because you disagree on them.
- Judging: Kialo has none. Policon's AI judge scores the argument rather than the position and shows its reasoning in a report afterwards.
- Progress: Kialo shows the map. Policon gives you a transcript, a breakdown by question and a chess-style rating.
- Subjects: Kialo covers anything. Policon is about politics and policy, with more than four hundred questions across eight areas, in eight languages.
Using both
The best way to prepare for a live debate is to read the strongest written case on both sides, and an argument map is one of the fastest ways to find it. A good routine is to map a question, pick the side you find harder to defend, and then argue it live against somebody who holds the other view. You learn more from that than from either half alone.